Small investors just sold like it’s March 2020

Share
Small investors just sold like it’s March 2020
CAPITALS INSIDERS
Markets, made simple — Midday edition · Friday, November 6, 2026
Good afternoon. This morning we covered what happened in Thursday's selloff. At midday, a closer look at who was selling. Individual investors sold more stock on Thursday than on any day since March 2020. That date is worth remembering, because of what came next.
 
🕛 Midday Desk
Individual investors just had their biggest selling day since 2020
A retired man at his kitchen table calmly looking at a falling chart on a tablet
Start with the data. According to Vanda Research, individual investors were net sellers of about $358 million of U.S. stocks on Thursday, their biggest selling day since March 17, 2020, when they sold about $502 million. "This is what we would call a total capitulation by retail investors," said Viraj Patel of Vanda Research. Capitulation is market shorthand for the point when worried investors give up and sell.
History is instructive here. Six days after that March 2020 selling day, on March 23, the S&P 500 hit its pandemic low and then began one of the fastest recoveries on record. That does not mean Thursday was a bottom; selling waves can last longer than anyone expects. But it is a reminder that the moments when selling feels most urgent have often been among the worst times to sell.
Individual investors headed for the exits
Retail selling and the fear gauge
Individual investors' net stock sales · millions of dollars, single day
Thursday, Nov. 5, 2026
 
$358M
March 17, 2020
previous record selling day
 
$502M
VIX volatility index ·
Before Thursday
approximately
 
16.5
Thursday's peak
 
27.45
Sources: Vanda Research via Yahoo Finance, November 5. The pre-selloff VIX level is approximate, derived from the reported 65% jump.
Professionals were selling too, for different reasons. Nomura's Charlie McElligott described hedge funds cashing in this year's winners. Kevin Mahn of Hennion & Walsh noted that after big gains, "this type of volatility shouldn't necessarily come as a surprise to anybody." The difference is that professionals often sell to rebalance, while individual investors more often sell out of fear, and fear-driven decisions tend to be the hardest to reverse at the right time.
If the past day has you uneasy, it can help to separate two questions: whether your mix of stocks, bonds and cash still fits your timeline and income needs, and whether a single day's headlines should change it. The first deserves a calm review. The second rarely has a good answer at the bottom of a bad day.
 
📈 By the Numbers
Retail net selling, Thursday
About $358 million; most since March 2020.
March 17, 2020
About $502 million; S&P 500 bottomed six days later.
VIX
Jumped as much as 65% to 27.45 on Thursday.
S&P 500, 2026
Still up 7.4% for the year through Thursday.
 
📜 Wisdom of the Street
“Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful.”
— Warren Buffett
Thursday showed what fear looks like in the data. What it means for the months ahead is still unknown.
 
Have a good afternoon.
— Lauren Miller, Capitals Insiders

Read more